Why Some Indonesian Women Choose Polygamy

31 year-old housewife Ratna Wulandari lives in Jakarta, Indonesia’s capital and most populated city, and is currently pregnant with her fourth child. Wulandari already has five children. Three are her own, and two belong to her husband’s first wife. She is in a happy polygamous marriage, and believes that other Indonesian women can embrace her example.

“Sister-wives help each other in marriage. I think polygamous marriage could be beneficial for women,” said Wulandari.

To the majority of women in Indonesia, Wulandari’s outlook is controversial. The practice is frowned upon in society even though it’s legal in the archipelago.

In Islam — the religion practiced by the vast majority of the population in Indonesia?—?polygamy is neither obligatory nor encouraged. A man taking up to four wives is considered mubah or “permissible” if a husband can be equally fair to all of his wives.

Under Indonesia’s civil marriage laws, polygamy is tightly restricted. An Indonesian Muslim man must provide a consent letter from his first wife. Then, a religious court decides if the polygamous marriage can be granted, taking into consideration things like terminal illness or infertility of the first wife.

Due to this restriction, many polygamous marriages in Indonesia are not lawfully registered. There’s no official number of legally approved polygamous marriages in Indonesia, but Siti Ruhaini Dzuhayatin, the founder of Indonesia’s first Women Crisis Center estimates they make up less than one percent of all registered marriages.

Many polygamists in Indonesia chose nikah siri, otherwise known as secret marriages. It’s usually held in front of a Muslim cleric and, in many cases, is conducted without the permission of the first wife.

While pro-polygamists have made multiple attempts to promote the virtue of having many wives, women’s rights activists in Indonesia speak out against polygamy and secret marriages because they’re seen as exploitative.

In a recent case, AyoPoligami — a dating app aimed to help polygamists find partners?—?was forced to shut down in August after an Indonesian feminist publication published a report that went viral, showing the platform was rife with seemingly dubious men looking for extramarital affairs. AyoPoligami founder Lindu Cipta Pranayama told reporters the app had amassed more than 56,000 users in just five short months. He made an attempt to relaunch it in October, with stricter rules for the men who sign up. But due to the public backlash, it hasn’t been able to regain its initial popularity, said Pranayama.

Wulandari never used AyoPoligami, but she thinks that the pro-polygamy community in Indonesia could benefit from having a stronger support system.

“It’s not easy being a woman in a polygamous marriage. I am aware of the negative light cast upon us. I never try to explain myself to people whom I know would blatantly oppose my choice,” said Wulandari, who refused to have her picture taken.

She added, “I usually just show them how a polygamous relationship can work, how I can get along very well with my sister-wife, how we help each other, and how we go out together a lot. That’s how I try to counter all the negative opinions.”

She and her husband’s first wife raise their children together. Their polygamous marriage is legally registered with the consent of the first wife, although Wulandari wouldn’t go into the detail of how she and her husband met.

According to Indonesia’s National Commission on Violence Against Women, there were more than 250,000 divorce cases in the country in 2015. In 7,476 of the cases, polygamy was cited as the cause of divorce, meaning some women prefer divorce over accepting another wife into the marriage.

Wulandari said she entered the polygamous relationship out of her own will, in following the religious teachings that she received.

“I first learned about polygamy in school, at Madrasa.” said Wulandari, pointing to a religious school she went to in Jakarta. “We are taught that polygamy is allowed in Islam. Men can have up to four wives, as long as all the necessary requirements are met.”

Her understanding about polygamy became deeper after she joined a polygamy seminar with Dauroh Poligami Indonesia (DPI) this year.

Dauroh Poligami Indonesia (DPI) is a Jakarta-based pro-polygamy group that organises a monthly ‘Polygamy Seminar’ in different cities in Indonesia. According to the group founder, Vicky Irawan Zaeni, the majority of participants of DPI’s polygamy seminars are women.

Indonesian women share experiences and knowledge at a DPI seminar. Credit: C2wire

The seminar advertises a “quick way to have four wives” and claims that it provides “real guidance” on the practice of polygamy. Getting in is expensive, setting male participants back around US$300 for a full-day session. To encourage female participation, the organisers give free access for women.

“I was already in a polygamous marriage when I joined, but the sessions gave me a better understanding. In the seminars, I heard various testimonies from other women, and in the end, we are all taught that in order for the marriage to work, men have to learn on how to maintain the well-being of their wives”, said Wulandari.

“For instance, if a man wants to take a second wife, he will need to make sure that his first marriage is healthy. It’s not about following a desire, it’s about making sure that you have enough knowledge about this practice,” she added.

“Most women are worried that taking a second, third, or fourth woman will wreck the marriage. They are worried that they will be given less affection by their husband. But it’s not right, it’s one hundred percent out of love to each wife, not fifty-fifty. It’s one hundred percent to the first, one hundred percent to the second, and so on.”

In her view, polygamy could even work better for women compared to monogamy. She said, “Every marriage is different, we can’t paint a general picture. But in my personal opinion, I think it’s beneficial for the women. I get to share duties with my sister-wife; our responsibilities as wives are shared, and we will still be given full rewards from Allah. Think of it as if you work for a company, you work for less, but you still get paid in full.”

When asked about if she has ever experienced setbacks in her marriage, Wulandari declined to elaborate. She said, “You know, sometimes you wish you could still spend more time with your husband, but he already has to meet his other wife. But it’s not a setback, it’s just a consequence.”

“All I can say to my sisters out there who are thinking about being in this kind of marriage is that they would have to do it because of Allah, and only Allah. If they don’t have that, of course it would be very hard to have to share your husband.”

Siti Ruhaini Dzuhayatin, founder of Indonesia’s Women Crisis Center, says some women are socially conditioned to accept polygamy.
Credit: C2wire

Siti Ruhaini Dzuhayatin of the Women’s Crisis Center said that Indonesian women living in a conservative hold are often socially conditioned to accept polygamy.

“They often think that entering a polygamous relationship, to have to share the marriage with another woman, is a better alternative than being an unmarried woman.”

“The fact that in Indonesia we still have a very male-centric society that enforces this stigma,” she explained. “Women are only seen as ‘worthy’ if they are married and if they can fulfill their duties as wives. This justification often conditions women to accept a polygamous relationship.”

For the last 15 years, Dzuhayatin — who currently serves as the vice-rector in the faculty of Syariah and Law at the Islamic State University in Yogyakarta — has been a strong advocate of women’s rights issues, working with various stakeholders in Indonesia including educators and public officials.

“It is our responsibility to try to change the perception that’s still there in society. If we want women to stop feeling socially imposed in accepting a polygamous relationship, we will need to make sure that our women have access to high-level education in Indonesia, and that they can be independent. There’s nothing wrong with being unmarried, even Islam doesn’t make it mandatory.”

She also pointed out that despite many pro-polygamy backers using religion as a pretext to push the agenda, polygamy is not part of Islamic teachings.

“Islam didn’t bring the concept of having multiple wives, the practice has existed since before Islam, where men in different civilizations can take as many wives as they want. What the religion seeks to do is to regulate the practice by limiting the number of wives a man can take,” explained Dzuhayatin. “It is actually monogamous marriages that are strongly promoted in the Quran.”


See: Polygamy is Still Tolerated in Indonesia, Advocates and Activists Speak Out